Tainted Love

Ebay has filed suit against craigslist and its board of directors:

http://news.ebay.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=305980

We are surprised and disappointed by Ebay’s unfounded allegations, which came to us out of the blue, without any attempt to engage in a dialogue with us.

Coming from a shareholder that views craigslist as a prime competitor, filing suit without so much as mentioning these assertions beforehand seems unethical, and hints at ulterior motives.

Ensuring the future well-being of craigslist and the craigslist community is admittedly very important to us. But Ebay has absolutely no reason to feel threatened here — unless of course they’re contemplating a hostile takeover of craigslist, or the sale of Ebay’s stake in craigslist to an unfriendly party. (In which case, they’re out of luck.

For our part, we have always treated Ebay very fairly as a minority shareholder, and plan to continue doing so, despite this unfortunate development.

Addendum in response to commenter question - To be perfectly clear, Ebay’s stake in craigslist has not been “unfairly diluted” as they have claimed.

217 Responses to “Tainted Love”

  1. Tom Geller Says:

    Courage, folks! I know you’ll get through this.

  2. Malcolm Says:

    Don’t give into their big business intimidation! I love craigslist, a lot more than ebay. Except for the fornications hook ups, but besides that, you guys rule!

  3. linda b Says:

    Oh yeah…let’s just kept letting the rich get richer…and the poor people who just wanting to make a penny here and there for either there old used stuff…or even some of our services offered to others…get “screwed” for lack of a better word… So power and strength in numbers to the developers of craigslist!! I would be more than happy to ask you to FIGHT…for what is right! This is one of the best sites available to people who DO NOT care to get involved in the ebay hype! Thank you craigslist…I hope you don’t give up, your doing a great service for so many people! I thank you and so do many many others.

  4. Craigslist sued by part-owner eBay [Updated] » VentureBeat Says:

    […] Craig responds on the company blog: […]

  5. Alexander Muse Says:

    Do you care to answer the charges? Did you dilute the minority shareholders? It is a fairly simple matter to determine. Love to get a comment on the facts, not your feelings…

  6. mathewingram.com/work | eBay to Craigslist: Oh no you didn’t Says:

    […] post at the newish Craigslist blog says that the company is: “surprised and disappointed by Ebay’s unfounded allegations, […]

  7. Kawika Holbrook Says:

    Whatever the particulars or merits of the suit, I’m sure Craigslist fans will stand by the company — especially with company notices titled “Tainted Love.” Classic.

  8. bill Philpott Says:

    You go guy. craigslist is great.

  9. Stormy Says:

    Thank you Craigslist for “keeping it real.”
    I love Craigslist for exactly the reason that Ebay is pushing people away.
    The basic, no frills, what you see is what you get free classifieds and events.
    Keep the big bad giant Ebay away.

  10. Chad Says:

    Missed Connections

    You (eBay): Middle aged, bitter, nerdy.
    Me (craigslist): young, indie, hip

    I saw you at the flee market. You told me own it … like I’d be impressed. You offered me a ride on your Harley … again like I’d be impressed. Your not cool.

    C

  11. Seymore Says:

    Personally, I’d dilute it with a poison pill! We all know how well eBay handles online classified services (Kijiji). We’d all be paying just to view CL if they had their evil way.

  12. Weary Pilgrim Says:

    Its some muscle flexing on the part of eBay

  13. fruity Says:

    Dear Craigslist and all that support what CL represents. Don’t give Obay 1 inch. They will desecrate this magical place called Craiglist. I can think of a million and one ways they continue to dilute buyers & sellers on their own site!

    In the meantime do you think you can let the eBayers back to being able to post links to their eBay listings! Right now it gets pulled. We need a place to trade in peace without having obay,paypal,skype or woestores microchip us. Maybe the peoples at CL will find it in their heart to support small business and invest in US. We all all hard workers. We dont need much either. We are used to not getting anything so it would be very easy to get us to be with you. IF there was only a place ….

    Fruity loves you

  14. fruity Says:

    if someone doesn’t stop the belly of the beast, pretty soon O-bay will charge us by the letter or for air. You will not be able to talk to one another without a skype phone, you cannot use anything but peepal and if you dont conform they will ding your twinkle stars. The internet was made to give us FREEDOM and be individuals!

  15. Larry Fritz Says:

    Good for you. eBay is a giant bloated nightmare. I’m surprised you sold them stock. Whatever, I love you and will totally stand behind you business model.

    I think eBay has made a mistake. The more noise they make the more folks will discover how cool CraingList is.

    Rock on.

    LF

  16. Richard Says:

    Ebay isn’t big business. It’s bad business.

  17. GAP Says:

    Go Craigslist. My prayers are with you. U will get out of this mess that eBay created stronger.

    “Thank you craigslist…I hope you don’t give up, your doing a great service for so many people! I thank you and so do many many others.” totally agree with linda above.

    … eBay Insider

  18. hd Says:

    ick. Their way of going about it does seem shady…. Best of luck and kick their arses. And don’t change a thing. Thank you for helping me move across the country.

  19. Todd Says:

    this sort of story only makes me love craigslist even more. thank you ebay! and oh yeah ebay: good luck with that crappy classifieds craigslist-knock-off site. i’ll be using the real craigslist.

  20. Pustoolio Says:

    @ Larry Fritz - eBay acquired the stock from an unnamed former Craigslist shareholder.

  21. Jennifer Says:

    feeBay has already alienated their userbase so much, I’m not surprised they’re feeling desperate. I considered selling my Nintendo DS on eBay, but then remembered about the unfair auction fees which were just marked up recently, and the fact I’d lose a cut if I did it through PayPal. Oh, not to mention the hassle of going to the post office. I put it up on Craigslist and got a response within hours, and my DS was sold locally the next day. I’ll never sell on feeBay ever again. I’m a loyal Craigslist fan and will be as long as they stick to their roots, which feeBay has not. I’m cheering for you!

  22. Lee Says:

    I don’t think CL sold them stock. A shareholder sold his interests in CL to eBay, which CL could do nothing about, they just had to make the best of a bad situation.

  23. Waery Says:

    Why don’t you answer the allegations. Did you or did you not try to squeeze out the minorities?

  24. Michael Says:

    Ebay is really a big bully crying foul when they themselves are the real aggressors. The love for ebay is not the company itself but what it stands for as contrast to craigslist that people love what you stand for and your site. I am new to craigslist but not ebay as they have and paypal there baby have really abused me as a customer.

    I really hate, hate, hate ebay and paypal. I am a powerseller there and they freeze your account, limit yeah, loose money in paypal etc. I have about 800 transactions plus and 1 negative on record but you think that means anything to them. NOPE, So never mind FEEBAY as they just want more money so make all craigslist free everywhere so they will sell out or you buy them out and be done with them. If you need a donation just email me as you have it. Thank You and LONG LIVE CRAIGSLIST!!!!!

  25. Inside Out Says:

    Yeah yeah yeah, eBay is a big giant bloated monster company as opposed to poor defenseless Craigslist, whose founders as we know are nearly penniless.

    I echo the comments above: beyond the puff and bullshit, what about these charges? Are they true? Did you guys do a “wash out job” to screw eBay? Facts? Hello?

    If the charges aren’t true why don’t you just explain why and how and we can all go on loving CL.

    I don’t love anybody who screws *anybody* out of their rightful money, and the millionaire founders of CL don’t get a pass because they run a cool website. They should be subject to the same rules as the rest of us.

    Just answer the charges in clear terms and we’ll all be happy to jump to your defense…

    SI

  26. Tigs Says:

    How can those of us who use CL everyday become a part of CL? Seriously, if everyone that uses Craigslist jumped in to help, we could make a powerful statement, as well as obtain some ownership in it by sticking together to preserve what we have here.

  27. EBay Sues Craigslist over ‘Dilution’ « Screenwerk Says:

    […] Here’s Jim (Buckmaster?) responding on the Craigslist blog. […]

  28. LG Says:

    This will turn out to be a nightmare for Ebay - they will end up losing so much goodwill (assuming they had any to begin with) - first you had the seller’s strike that eroded Ebay’s image, now this - what a bunch of sad bullies!

    Craigslist will always be the best!

  29. Adam Smith Says:

    Can you explain more about what you actually did with respect to diluting eBay’s stake in CL? I can’t find anything that explains this on the web.

    Thanks.

  30. Collantes.US — Entries — eBay sues Craigslist Says:

    […] to an eBay Press release: Tainted Love We are surprised and disappointed by Ebay’s unfounded allegations, which came to us out of the […]

  31. Betty May Iler Says:

    Gave up using E-bay as soon as I discovered Craigslist, no fees is the very reason. Can’t afford all the fees everytime you post something on E-bay, and for what?
    Hang in there Craiglist, E-bay has nothing on you and your great site!!

  32. Freight88 Says:

    eBay is not the 800 lb Gorilla. No site is perfect and CL has it’s share of issues (flagging) but I back CL not eBay.

    Bad publicity is publicity.

  33. commoncents Says:

    Dear Craig Newmark and Jim Buckmaster- We applaud you . Dump those dirt bags of ebay -put them where they belong! Pound ebay into the next cyber world. Get Ebay off you backs - no matter what it takes… and then take ebay and Paypal away from them. All’s fair in love and war.

    Craigslist- You’ve got a cheering team here for ya- and we’ve got your backs. Dont let those corporate bullies at Ebay think they even have a chance.
    If anybody has some dirt to unload about Ebay - Now is the time to it pass on the the Craigslist People- go for it… spill away.
    Craigslist has always been a great place to hang-chat-etc.
    Thanks Guys- for showing the world -that Ebay isn’t the almighty powerful ones they think they are. They can’t even maintain what they’ve got … and now they want Craigslist- NO WAY!
    Craig Newmark and Jim Buckmaster- we stand with you all the way !The Good will prevail!

  34. jackpinesavage Says:

    Appears 1 individual had this as a plan for some time. Thats how takeovers generally proceed.like a snake in the grass. Get a glimpse of the technique in the Movie “Meet Joe Black’ i like the way CR is and would be disheartened if it turns out to be another part of the vast censoreship {ed} sites that go that way once too popular & bought out for $$ & control of the worlds information dissemination. ie, google & youtube. The think-tank plans are Written all over the tunnel walls. Dam shame.

  35. Phil Koenig Says:

    CL did not sell them stock intentionally. Ebay received it when an ex-CL employee with a ~25% stake went to Ebay, looking to sell it. Apparently there was nothing in the agreement with CL that precluded the sale to an outside corporate entity (and potential competitor) such as Ebay.

  36. patriciam Says:

    please don’t give in. they’re ruining all of this and this is one of the few decent experiences left on line.

  37. Seemore Says:

    Come now Craig, if you were just more transparent about the whole ownership structure you would not get yourself, and others, into this mess.

  38. eBay gets it’s knickers in a wist « Ladgeful Says:

    […] year financial investment”. Sounds to me like eBay is getting desperate. Craigslist blog post here. eBay press release here. […]

  39. CEP Says:

    ebay has become increasingly cumbersome and costly. I’ll take craigslist any day. Hope you smack the giant down. They continue to try to bribe and or coerce any other online venue to join them under their umbrella. Too bad the umbrella is full of holes. Sales are down, market share is dropping. They have no customer service and every touted attempt to bring security to their site causes more problems. ebay constantly ignores many of it’s users complaints.
    The disruption strategy isnt working as planned. Hopefully CL will win this fight and ebay can go back and sulk in their corner of the internet and leave one of the best sites for buying and selling on the internet alone.

  40. Boycott Ebay Says:

    The only surprise here is that Ebay didn’t pull something like this sooner.

    It’s hypocritical, at best, that they complain of being “disadvantaged” when that’s what they do to their own paying customers - the sellers. The Ebay business model is to pay your fees and they will hide your listings behind countless scammers and counterfeiters.

  41. Shelina Says:

    Good luck and I’m behind you all the way. eBay needs a serious spanking. I find their behavior these days just bizarre; they’ve turned into an insatiable monster and they need to be stopped!

  42. DS Says:

    Ebay is threatened by you folks. After the recent changes at Ebay customers of Ebay ( including me) are flocking to Craigs. Lots of discussions on their fourms about customers fed up and leaving for a much better way to sell things.

    Let us know how we can support you!

    THX

  43. ptoone Says:

    Go Craigslist!

  44. Mere Says:

    Just one more ploy by ebaY to get their name in the headlines while their dirty little house of cards is falling fast.

    You go CL….ebaY, like it used to be, is almost over and they are looking for any money they can get their greedy little hands on.

    They only wish that their crappy little Kijiji could be like CL…which will never happen.

  45. SueG Says:

    Go craigslist!!!! Give ‘em hell!

    I hate ebay

  46. Hugene Says:

    Good luck guys, all my encouragement is for you.

  47. Genevieve McGill Says:

    Dear Craig’s List, I LOVE U VERY MUCH!!! PRETTY-PLEASE let me know if I can do ANYTHING to support you. I am a Powerful,Licensed Massage therapist in FL who will use ALL of My intellectual BICEPS & anything I’ve got to be your dutiful minion.

  48. DelectablyYoursDecor Says:

    Does eBay Practice Fiduciary Duty of Loyalty To It’s Sellers?

    ebay has no regard for it’s sellers financial investment in their company yet has the nerve to file a law suit against an entrepreneur who has a better platform than they do…

    eBay sellers acted in good faith with them; opened stores, purchased inventory, spent time consuming hours listing all our items in the store, building reputation and business only to be forced out because we now don’t fit their new master plan.

    Does eBay, their representatives and subsidiaries make truthful and complete disclosures to those placing trust in them? Are they not obtaining an unreasonable advantage at the latter’s expense?

    Kudos Craigslist!!! We all wish you the best in slaying the dragon!

  49. Sam Says:

    It is simple, E-bay are a pack of whores who’s greed over paid by 10X for Skype. Craigslist is a class act who I have used over 100 times with great results, I cannot say the same for E-bay. Let’s get real this is pure revenge because Cargslist is making an impact E-bay’s bottomline I will never use E-bay again after this BS

  50. Tlhnbud Says:

    Ebay is out of line. Capitalism is built on fair competition. Ebay has gotten out of hand with its fees.

  51. Dorothy Says:

    No worries. People hate Ebay - they just screwed over millions of users. If it comes to Craigslist or Ebay, people are going with Craigslist, no doubt.

    Buy your stock back if you can. Just the fact that Ebay owns some of your stock is unsettling after their recent actions. Distance yourself from Ebay, they aren’t going to fair well long term.

  52. Craigslist responds to eBay lawsuit « IT Spot Says:

    […] Craigslist has responded to eBay’s lawsuit, noting it “came to us out of the blue,” according to a posting on its craigslist blog Tuesday. […]

  53. Idontpostmynameonline Says:

    Fight them every step of the way. They are big bullies, they got rid of Yahoo auctions so that when they started kicking their sellers around they would have fewer decent options. :(

  54. DiddyMau Says:

    I really don’t know what the allegations are, nor what the facts are, and quite frankly I don’t care. I’d like to see FeePay (a.k.a. ebay) and their sister PayPal, be deleted, in one quick key stroke.

  55. De Koopman » Blog Archive » eBay daagt Craigslist voor de rechter: ‘vervuilt ons aandeel’ Says:

    […] luidt de eerste reactie van Craig Newmark en Jim Buckmaster van Craigslist. Waarom? Ebay daagt het bedrijf voor de rechter […]

  56. fnar.co.uk » Blog Archive » Boycott Day Beckons Says:

    […] it appears that ebay is taking legal action against popular website craigslist. Now, I’m slightly worried. If I owned a stake in a company (even if it was a minority 28pc […]

  57. Happilyfaceless Says:

    How can we who enjoy the benefits of Craigslist help in dissuading eBay? Would a one month boycott of eBay help twist their arm.

  58. ayrton1 Says:

    I love CL and wish you guys good luck for the good fight. To add to Dorothy’s advice, in addition to buying your stock back, hopefully you have already pinged each and every CL stock holder to ensure against a hostile take over.

    In all fairness, I like ebay too, but the ease of use, local outreach and of course the FREE factor, makes CL no. 1 for me.

    Now I wish you guys could have sued ebay when they started kijiji….but then that is the difference between CL and ebay.

  59. maria Says:

    back off ebay….you big companies want everything….if someone if offering something free to someone…..0mg….your not making any money…7.7 million last year..w0w….greed is comsuming you…..leave craiglist alone!

  60. Craigslist grouses about eBay lawsuit - pcpartfinder Says:

    […] Craigslist has responded to a lawsuit filed by eBay, noting that it "came to us out of the blue," according to a posting on its craigslist blog Tuesday. […]

  61. Kyle Says:

    I have a suggestion for you.

    Make a free auction site. Their market cap will drop immediately. You have more power over them than they over you. A lot more. All you have to do is threaten to go in the auction business.

    Screw them.

  62. Chris in Buffalo Says:

    Craigslist should remove Ebay as a Minority Shareholder because THEY (Ebay) are the predator… and if they (Ebay) had their way, Craigslist would be off the web. Isn’t a Kajiji a sorry mock and lame copy of Craigslist?

  63. sg Says:

    Wasn’t it obvious from the beginning that eBay’s investment in craigslist had some end like this in mind? They have every reason in the world to want to destroy craigslist. Now that they’ve finally decided to attack, I imagine it’s going to get pretty bloody before it’s over.

  64. greta Says:

    ~ JOIN THE WORLD WIDE eBay BOYCOTT ~ BE INFORMED ~

    Find your State or International Location folder and join us. Former employees are welcome too!

    A place to organize.
    A place to unite.
    A place to focus.
    United we stand, Divided we fall.

    http://forums.delphiforums.com/boycottebay
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zs3o3Ed3Rog
    http://www.accknowl.com/

    Boycott Victoriously … While Making Noise!
    Evacuate by May 1, 2008!

    Please support Australia’s protest and sign the petition:
    http://www.petitiononline.com/ebayau/petition.html

  65. Nerd Says:

    I’ve been out of the finance game for awhile now, but wouldn’t it make sense (if a majority of stock is held preferred) that CL call its stock and get eBay out of its bed?

  66. JT Says:

    As a lawyer with experience in these matters, I would love to see details on eBay’s claim on how craigslist “diluted” eBay’s ownership stake in contravention of DE law. In fact, this type of anti-takeover action is quite common and routinely upheld in the states of DE, MD, and so on. Certainly a claim that the directors have violated their fiduciary duties is tenuous. Is eBay trying to “browbeat” craigslist with non-meritorious claims?…

  67. JT Says:

    In response to Nerd’s comment about calling stock (regardless of whether it is common or preferred); it is not a good option for craigslist either financially or for the long-term control of the company.

  68. Pat Kenefick Says:

    How did eBay acquire an ownership interest in craiglist? My understanding is that craigslist is a privately held company…

  69. job board news Says:

    shame on ebay! i would love to see this backfire on them.

  70. meryl Says:

    Thank you eBay:) I had not heard of Craigslist until now and very pleased to be here.

  71. Wango Says:

    It’s like this:

    Craigslist = beloved
    eBay = tolerated

    Now…

    Craigslist = beloved
    eBay = another bad business decision. Not even tolerated.

    eBay is bad and getting worse.

  72. Nerd Says:

    JT - I’m not sure how you can make that statement. Are you privy to information regarding cash position or current ROR of investments?

    If they have excess cash that is currently earning a low ROR what better investment could they make than in their own stock?

    Assuming they believe their own stock is going to grow.

  73. Junkbuzzed: sex, lies, and .jpgs Says:

    […] But the best part is Craigslist’s response.  In typical Craigslist fashion (re: angry dude who isn’t getting his way), they posted a blog entitled “Tainted Love“. […]

  74. Articles of Interest, April 23, 2008 « The American Muslim Says:

    […] Craigslist has responded to a lawsuit filed by eBay, noting that it “came to us out of the blue,” according to a posting on its craigslist blog Tuesday. […]

  75. Ob1 Says:

    Feeborg/ Payfool’s M.O:
    http://www.powersellersunite.com/viewtopic.php?p=152006#152006
    ( excerpt)
    “Like Pharaoh or any other true tyrant, eBay doesn’t wait for prophesy to be realized, but instead kills in infancy. This is how it has come to be –and remains, according to Forbes– the #1 e-commerce brand worldwide. (The key word there is brand.) With the exception of Skype (which was not a competitor per se anyway), eBay buys out rivals when they are comparatively cheap, otherwise they simply sue. BidBay, trademark infringement, zapped, WorldAuctions.com, accused of having a feedback system, must be infringing, calls for injunction, whap, Alternabay, infringing, slap, Brickbay site for Legos, infringing, slap, slap,…….More often they see who is positioned to dominate any market and buy them before they get too big.
    Since eBay went public it has been gorging on rivals and would-be peers of all kinds:
    –1998, Up4Sale.com eaten up for pocket change
    –1999, Butterfield & Butterfield consumed (and later spit out to Bonhams at a profit), also German Alandus consumed and made into eBay.de
    –2000, Half.com consumed, eventually made into eBay Marketplaces
    –2001, MercadoLibre (Latin America) and iBazar (France) consumed
    –2002, PayPal
    –2003, the Chinese EachNet and Internet Auction Co. (Korea)
    –2004, Marktplaats.nl (83% share of Dutch market) and Baazee.com swallowed up (Baazee to become eBay India), while 25% share of Craigslist taken, plus acquisition of Rent.com.
    –2005, UK Gumtree, German OpusForum, and Spanish Loquo (all classifieds), plus Shopping.com and Skype bought up
    –2006, Swedish Tradera consumed, networking site MeetUp.com bought, and some nebulous deal with Google also confirmed, but details not fully disclosed
    –2007, StubHub (tickets sales) consumed, GittyGidiyor.com (main Turkish auction site) underway, and StumbleUpon bought up (like a Digg for websites), plus Kijiji (classifieds) extended to the US (already being a market leader in Germany, Canada, France, Italy, China, India, Taiwan, and significantly, Japan)…….As to the Craigslist issue, a look at Kijiji is instructive. It is direct competition for Craigslist, which of course eBay already partly owns, and raises the question, will Craig sell to Kijiji rather than eBay? (EBay often starts out with only a minority share, e.g., EachNet, IAC, etc.) In the same way that an auction site depends critically on traffic, so do on-line classifieds. It looks to me that eBay would like to dominate non-print media classifieds the way they dominate e-auctions so bringing Kijiji to the US extends this effort, puts a choke collar on Craigslist, and also serves a purpose with Google Base. (Still only beta, has nothing to do with auctions now, but Google lists eBay items via Google Base Store Connector, they show up heavily in Product Finder, and there was also the deal in which Google became the single text-based advertiser for eBay in all non-US markets.)
    EBay’s true goal seems to be to position itself, in one way or another, to get a cut of everything anyone attempts to sell outside of a brick-and-mortar store. ”

    The good news is that CL has shown that the model works. The key may be for a PRIVATELY OWNED company structure.

  76. May Truong Says:

    What eBay wants from craigslist is for it to go away and die in a corner. It’s that simple. You don’t trust a company that has a history of hyper-aggression towards any and all competition. I am a member of eBay but they are my second, if not third, choice. Whatever I am trying to accomplish in the marketplace, I consider craigslist first, and clearly what eBay would like is that I have no choice, as they would be the only choice. I have described craigslist to those who are unfamiliar as the Wild Wild West. In this shootout with eBay, I wish you all the best so to Craig, Jim and all who have changed the world as we know it … Go East and kick some ass.

  77. Steve Says:

    Everyone STOP using ebay for ANYTHING until they quit the unmerited lawsuit against CL. And email them just WHY you are quitting their bloated service.
    Craig, this too, will pass. Use your best lawyers to vigorously defend, and know that there are million CL users who will also help if asked.

  78. patriciam Says:

    I’ll repeat what’s been said a few times. What can we do to help?

  79. Dean H. Says:

    Ebay is going to need that stock. It was a very good investment. When the whole world has learned about Craigslist and no longer uses eBay, they can live on the proceeds of their CraigsList stock.

  80. Craigslist calls eBay lawsuit 'unethical' | InfoWorld | News | 2008-04-23 | By Grant Gross, IDG News Service Says:

    […] fired back in a blog post. “We are surprised and disappointed by Ebay’s unfounded allegations, which came to us out of the […]

  81. Early Says:

    Craigslist should start a PayPal account and allow people to donate money to help CL with this lawsuit. There would be a nice irony in that.

  82. Ob1 Says:

    This move comes as no surprise given the history. So the other aspect of FeeBorg I’ve been wondering about: Where is the FTC / other US Gov depts involved with Antitrust/ monopolistic practices? Or has ebay ‘bought’ enough political influence to keep a coin operated(?) Gov. from going after it? I would think this would be among the logical counter-moves.
    How would FTC respond to massive requests by citizens & groups such as CL community members to go after the ebay monopoly? Shall we find out together? THEM’S FIGHTIN’ WORDS, ARRRR!

  83. oztion mopsy Says:

    Which part of NO does eBay not understand? N for nick or O for off

  84. Melissa Stormer Says:

    eBay is a bully and has a bullying culture. It is a place that rewards this type of behavior in its leaders. As a former eBayer — I know first hand. Don’t be intimidated by a bully.

    Craig - you did the right thing by calling them out.

  85. Brien Says:

    What is up with the management team at craigslist? These jack#$%’s have no idea how to run a company. They wouldn’t have all the problems they’re facing if there was more then two people on their board, Craig and Jim. The closed nature of craigslist is the root to their problems. Big companies need a certain level of transparency to keep them honest. If they were smart they would expand their board including the CEO of eBay.

  86. Dan B. Says:

    I just cashed out of Paypal (E(vil)Bay’s evil step child - I left them with the .20 cents they gave me to verify my account. I won’t use e(vil)Bay again - not even for comparison shopping - as the prices aren’t real…

  87. Andrea 'Enthal Says:

    I haven’t used used Craigslist (yet) though I knew of your existence.
    But you have just earned a whole book of adhesive gold stars in my esteem now.
    I will see if I can use Craigslist somehow in the future.

    EBay has become a greedy bully, forcing their sellers off their site (by fee-ing them to death) and attempting to force their proprietary and unsafe system of Paypal down all members throats with lies that it is for their own protection (when it is really for eBay’s unearned profits).

    Go David. Rah, rah, rah David. Aim that slingshot at Goliath.
    Don’t let Goliath bully you or take over you as they are trying to do with all their competition.

    You have earned my respect by taking on this bully.
    EBay has earned the contempt of thousands (maybe millions) of formerly loyal members, by their recent short term profit -only business plan.
    Stay true to your convictions and don’t let them suck your company dry.
    We, who never paid attention to Craigslist before, are out here, taking notice, and liking what we see.

  88. Chuck Ebay! Says:

    And Paypal along with them. Craigslist is the real deal and always keeps it real. These companies have lost it entirely. Don’t give in to them. Don’t even wait around for them to try again. Buy out their shares and send them packing. Give us a number. We’ll altogether buy their arses out! The war against the haves and the have nots will be won by us! Hillary GO HOME!
    EBAY GO HOME! Corporate outsourcers…just die!

  89. salvagemaster Says:

    For all the people that want to know the TRUTH? Why do you confront CL about providing the details of the lawsuit the EBAY has filed? Do you not think that the burden of proof should lie with the the plaintiff? Why does EBAY not provide the details of their complaint with craigslist? Probably because this is just another attempt to run a competitor against the wall by making them come up with hundreds of thousands of dollars to defend against a lawsuit that might not even have any real grounds.
    In the legal system, two parties face off until one runs out of money, and then the other has won. In the e-world today, who do you think has a bigger budget for lawyers, EBAY or CL?

  90. Mike Says:

    Hmm I think Ill Start a brand new site called “Free Bay ”

    fuckers

  91. Giovanni Says:

    Say ‘NO!’ to
    Korporate Kommie Krapitalism

    Say NO! to ebay!

  92. Rosalinda Says:

    ebaY purchased Craiglist stock in a backdoor and sleazy way - the standard ebaY operatiing method. There is no doubt some nasty and nefarious plan behind this ebaY suit, but unfortunately ebaY HAS bought way more influence than should be legal! No one is regulating ebaY/PayPal so they will do whatever they want, whenever they want, until someone has the deep enough pockets to sue them successfully without settlement, or some legislator has the guts to regulate them.

    There is already an ebaY Boycott scheduled starting 1 May 08, and this suit is one more VERY good reason for everyone to cease doing business on ebaY, buying, or selling. Even better, move ALL your ebaY business to CL - that would be a real kick!

  93. John Says:

    eBay is nothing but a bunch of cry babies. They bneed to wake up to the fact that what they own of craigslist is all they are going to get. Nobody wants eBay here they do need to move on. If they are so unhappy then sell the stock they own and move on no hard feelings. If they are going to this much trouble over nothing then that clearly shows that they are dis-honest and are using this as a way to gain ground on craigslist. Just more bad behavior from eBay, for once they found someone they CAN’T push around.

  94. FIGHT Says:

    eBAY sucks dick anyway; don’t give up.

  95. jahjesters now at onlineauction.com Says:

    Ebay is attacking craigslist just as they have attacked other entities that threaten their MONOPOLY of the online market. They will attempt to OWN c/l just like they did with preypal, skype and others.

    What’s next? Ebay going to go after onlineauction.com? Ioffer? ecrater? etsy? all the rest?

    Join the worldwide boycott http://www.myspace.com/boycottebay or http://www.forums.delphiforums.com/boycottebay

  96. Gail W. Says:

    Stick to your guns, Craigslist. Any FREE online classified ads has my backing (even tho I don’t like CL’s ‘flag ads’ that is exploited on the Pets section!). Something smells rotten in de bay, since the beginning of this year esp., like they themselves have been a victim of a hostile takeover. CYA!

  97. AMERICAN NONSENSE » Craigslist vs. eBay: The Ultimate Online Auction Catfight Says:

    […] its 28% shareholder ownership of the company. Craigslist then fired back with some pointed blog postings and claimed the bad guys over at eBay were acting […]

  98. Palladio Strategy Ltd. » Blog Archive » Filed Under “gossip” Says:

    […] an appropriately named Blog post, a posting called “Tainted Love“, Craig says “Ebay has absolutely no reason to feel threatened here - unless of course […]

  99. Law Blog - WSJ.com : EBay Sues Craigslist, Claiming Dilution Says:

    […] a blog entry posted on its site Tuesday night, Craigslist said it was

  100. Alex H. Says:

    Love craigslist….. Down with ebay!!!!

  101. Jeff Says:

    I am sure craigslist with get through this. I love both craigslist and ebay not sure what ebay’s motives are behind this.

    I feel this mostly have to do with the competition that craigslist poses to ebay. Just send a open notice to all craigslist users we are all united and ready to help

  102. jack Says:

    You hang in there craigslist…Ebay is just getting greedier and greedier all the time..

  103. Rick Says:

    It is amazing and shocking to me that anybody would take side with eBay on this. Craigslist owners have set-up a great precedent of what all in the world need to learn - just enough that you need. Going beyond that is greedy. I liked the quote where Craig said (paraphrasing) “I make money and then find ways to give it back - instead, I will leave it this way”.

    eBay and all other large corporations represent greedy people - and they have no clue what mess they have got themselves into!

  104. Rick Says:

    Digg this Blog posting here:

    http://digg.com/tech_news/eBay_Has_Filed_Suit_Against_Craigslist

  105. David D. Says:

    Thank you for informing me of this. Now I realize how much of a scumbag company eBay is.

  106. Fruity Says:

    does anyone notice ebays reaction is also similar to what they did to Google checkout almost a year ago? Google check out invited everyone to join them for the Boston Tea Party at Ebay Live and then ebay pulled the Google adwords like a day later. Tantrum management huh? What do you all think about that? Maybe we can all send them some of those big baby pacifiers or personalized baby bibs just like what they did for the Jericho TV show with the peanuts! We could go viral everybody. Lets show them the power of all of US in the magical community of Craigslist! Just because we can!

  107. jb Says:

    Fight them.
    I already sent them an email stating that I will leave ebay if they dont stop whast theyre doing. I despise monopolistic behemoths. I do a lot f ebaying but ill close my account.

    Ill live.
    jb

  108. I have an idea, hurry hurry « FHC Says:

    […] they were going to delivery peanuts to the CBS offices to fight for Jericho to be renewed? I posted this on the Craigslist blog this morning. does anyone notice ebays reaction is also similar to what they […]

  109. Phill Says:

    “they will end up losing so much goodwill (assuming they had any to begin with)”

    No, I can attest that they in fact, have *no* goodwill. Not to mention the bloodsucking paypal doesn’t either.

    Frankly, if ebay wants to pursue this crap, maybe people need to look in to regulating ebay’s countless scam auctions like giving full disclosure as to their rates. Also, maybe provide some *real* customer service. And, it’s time that paypal be regulated like the bank it pretends to be.

    I take much comfort in the fact that as ebay scrolls through these posts that they can do nothing to delete them,l like they do over on their own site. One has to wonder if that’s what they really want to do here.

  110. ONLINE SERVICES/INTERACTIVE MEDIA « Daily Marauder Says:

    […] (Iwantmedia 4/23, http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2008/04/22/BUKE10A0NV.DTL 4/23, http://blog.craigslist.org/2008/04/tainted-love […]

  111. Jodi Says:

    I am sick and tired of Ebay gobbling up their competition and that is what I believe they are up to. Just another reason why I am glad I jumped the Ebay ship as it is the Titanic —- sinking into the abyss—–just another Amazon wanabee.

  112. ebay sues craigslist, won’t say why Says:

    […] and there are concerns that the lawsuit is part of an attempt to seize the rest. craigslist seems baffled by the whole thing: We are surprised and disappointed by Ebay’s unfounded allegations, which […]

  113. Tammy Says:

    This is total bull****. Why can’t people just get their riches on there own. Craigslist is a totally awesome way for people to sell or get rid of stuff they no longer want. I will never stop using Craigslist. I have bought quite a few things on it and will continue. EBay is totally out of line here, how exactly are they being “theatened”? They make enough money, leave Craigslist alone!

  114. no name Says:

    Excellent posts of support.

    Now, someone must STAND UP and purchase these 28% from eBay.
    Come on, folks, now, really. What would it take? Just get it off bastard’s hands.

  115. LM Says:

    Behind CL 200%

    You should start an auction site- you have something Ebay’s lost - RESPECT.

    Good luck!

  116. David Says:

    As an online merchant, I recall the days when I received bogus emails saying ” I want to purchase your products, but will only do so if you accept Paypal”

    In response, I told the respective customer not to hold their breath. I do Not accept Paypal today, I will never accept Paypal ever.

    We still don’t, merchants who use Pay Pal, are generally not approved by Banks as Legitimate Merchants, hence they trade by Paypal.

    Your friends will be soooo jealous..

  117. Seemore Says:

    “To be perfectly clear, Ebay’s stake in craigslist has not been unfairly diluted as they have claimed.”

    So was it diluted fairly?

    And what about the allegations you were diluting poor Knowlton too?

  118. Jrdn Says:

    Pat Kenefick,

    Craigslist never sold stock shares to Ebay, one of their shareholders did so in secret and the sale wasn’t known until after the fact. Slick ebay tactics and imho, they placed a mole in Craigslist to achieve this sale. Ebay’s been trying to get a hold of more Craigslist stock ever since and for no other reason than to take it over or crush it out of existence to be replaced with yet another ebay monopoly.

  119. Some Smo Says:

    Wow, surprised there are a few eBay shills here. Hey, CL doesn’t have to give you any info about its internal financials because it’s a privately held company. Lawsuit documents are sealed, why is that? You should be asking eBay, but then you’re really paid by them.

  120. Paolo Bakeca.it Says:

    Hey guys you are #1!!! I think Ebay have some problems …. and this lawsuit is the most stupid move they’ve done. We are a little classified site in Italy… but not as little than kijiji ! :-)) we all are fan of craigslist!!! Have a lot of luck Craig & Jim and please….. let ebay enjoy their minority stake ! hahahahaha …. Paolo

  121. LizJ Says:

    GO CRAIGSLIST GO. I am not used to feeling strongly about anything but Craigslist is an exception, its just a great, great, service for the average person who wants to get real things done in their life. Whereas EBAY got me a pair of “lightly used” ugg boots that looked like road kill. Thanks Craigslist, thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks. I will march for you, bike for you and I will even WEAR those ugh boots just to make a point.

  122. TAB Says:

    Like many others here, I love Craigslist. I may not have used it to the extent that others have, but over the years it’s no doubt saved me hundreds if not thousands of dollars in listing fees had I used eBay or newspaper classifieds. And the friendships I’ve made with people met through Craigslist (mostly roommates) I consider priceless.

    To that end, I have an idea for how you could offer to buy out eBay’s shares without having to come up with a large sum of money. Pick a generous valuation for the stock…hopefully it’s around or under $200 per share. Then, through the Craigslist site, allow users to purchase 1-10 shares each. Make sure that every buyer agrees to a legalese document limiting shareholder rights (like the minority shareholder rights to sue that eBay is exercising). You could even allow these shares to be traded on the Craigslist website, so they won’t be valueless.

    I see this as a win for everyone, with the possible exception of eBay should their motivation be to sabotage Craigslist. For eBay, they get to sell their shares at a profit. For Craigslist, the eBay lawsuit goes away and the core community values are strengthened. And for us users, it gives us a chance to own a small piece of an organization that we believe in and makes our lives better.

    (IANAL, of course, so there could be some legal reason why this idea wouldn’t work)

  123. Dolphie Says:

    Even if Craigslist diluted the shares - so what? Many companies dilute their shares for various reasons.
    Ebay’s possession of Craigslist stock was a hostile takeover as they were unsolicited by the main partners. The partner who sold out to eBay is a self-absorbed and potentially immature jerk. They knew what they were doing and they sold out a great site - against the wishes of the other partners who built the site.
    There are too many monopolies growing out there. KUDOS to craigslist for staying their own course and not selling out for the money. I am sure it would be an easier decision to sell of their baby and move on to another venture - but they don’t. This keeps the site free for us to access and use.
    Ebay is just another google - sellouts.
    I believe strongly in capitalism - I also do not believe that healthy capitalism includes gluttony or greed.

  124. Bill Says:

    C’mon, did you REALLY think Egay buying a stake in CL was a GOOD thing?? Please. Ebay is the biggest SCUMBAGS on the web. Craig, bubby, you can’t be THAT dumb, can ya? Well, you’re a web developer, so that’s one strike. But THINK about it. Well, CL has been going downhill themselves for a while now, so, it’ll be crash and burn, hopefully for both. The egos always take over

  125. Suprum (seabass) Says:

    Fuck Ebay. Simply put… Fuck Ebay.
    Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em,Fuck ‘em, FUCK ‘EM!

    Jesus, come on… you’re going to pick on a dot org??? really, Ebay?
    Trying to kill the spirit of honest, easy and casual exchange of product,idea and social connection through a simple, easy and consistent resource,e.g. craigslist? you suck and you know it, too.

    I hope you burn down in a firery helicopter crash like leonard skynard!

    Account removed as of today and nexer to return.

    Good luck, craig and remember, you have the support of an entire community behind you–

    Cheers!

  126. Glenn Says:

    I just pulled all my adds and watches off ebay. Maybe if enough people do the same, this greedy corporation will get the message to back off c-list.

    Boycott ebay!

  127. kingair157 Says:

    Craigslist is great. EBay is very greedy. How can we help? Community in action!! The Craigslist community!

  128. Sandy Says:

    Hang in there guys! While I am primarily an eBay seller, using Craigslist only occasionally, the manner in which eBay does business is questionable at best. As far as I’m concerned, Craigslist is yours and if the courts have half a brain, they will rule in your favor. If there is anything that we can do, please let us know. I’m quite certain the small and vintage sellers on eBay will be behind you all the way :)

  129. hans garcia Says:

    abajo el puto ebay monopolio
    fuck ebay monopoly

  130. Michael Says:

    Anymore eBay is a joke. New Mr, CEO John Don-Hole will stop at nothing to destroy eBay with some of the stupidest ideas I have seen. To get my business degree I had to work my ass off, this guy Mr. Don-Hole must have gotten his out of a box of Cracker Jack. It’s not enough that he is hell bent of killing what little business there is left on eBay, but now he has to pick o other people as well. What’s the matter don-Hole is Kijiji not working out for you the way you wanted it to? It sure is a bitch when you run into someone that you can’t bully, you run with your tail betwin your legs and cry foul and sue. You are a real big man, just wait for your fall to come. I would just love to see Craigslist start an auction site and put your ass out of work just like all the others that you have run off ebay, And if your are reading this Don-Hole you are a moron kiss my ass. Is that enough NOISE for you

    Somewhere in the world a village is missing it’s idiot, just look on eBay you will find him he’s the guy running the company.

  131. Jan Says:

    Ebay is a big bully who is obviously playing dirty! Craiglist is offering for free what they charge for so they are using strongarm legal manuevers to squash Craiglist! It’s simple and easy to use. I haven’t used Ebay in years, the site got too complex and it was hard to use for local stuff. I discovered Craiglist last year and it’s the greatest!

    I’m sure Ebay planned this all along in a backroom with their coniving team of unscrupulous lawyers! I’ll never use that site again.

  132. Anthony Says:

    Key words minority share holder!!!!!!

  133. Pissed Says:

    Craigslist is public? Ebay fucking has stock in Craigslist? Holy shit!

    Is there a competitor for Ebay i can use from now on????

  134. Don Says:

    I am extremely happy with Craigslist and more than a little disapointed with eBay.

    The good folks at Craigslist are providing a great service to individual buyers and sellers that is sincerely appreciated.

    Keep up the good work. Don’t let the greedy slugs at eBay get you down!

  135. o.c.d.collectibles Says:

    Everyone must patronize craigslist on a certain week or day, by listing something for sale. If everyone listed just ONE thing that they normally would have listed on feebay, that would be so special!

    Pick a day, any day will do! ;-)

  136. Don Says:

    In fairness to eBay. I think we should all call eBay’s Media contact and get their side of the story.

    Media Contact
    Kim Rubey, eBay Inc.
    408.376.7458

  137. Unethical Says:

    i own the unethical.com domain name.

    would you guys like to use it for a bit?

    joe

  138. Steve Says:

    I think we all love Craigslist… but that’s not really the issue here. Let’s not be too hasty to jump to conclusions.

    All I really know so far is that EBay isn’t happy with the fact that Mr. Newmark and Mr. Buckmaster allegedly diluted EBay’s ownership interest unfairly and without representation.

    As I understand it EBay owns (or owned prior to dilution) 28% of Craigslist. That’s a pretty big chunk, and in most companies it’s worthy of board representation. If you buy 28% of something, you ought to have some say in what happens to it. But my understanding of Craigslist’s board is that Mr. Newmark and Mr. Buckmaster are the only two members, and that EBay is not represented at all. (A two person board member consisting only of insiders is generally not considered proper corporate governance anyway.)

    And what Mr. Newmark and Mr. Buckmaster apparently did was reduce EBay’s ownship stake of the company without EBay’s OK, which is a legitimate beef if it’s true. (Would you want your bank reducing your savings account balance by 10% without your permission?)

    If that is indeed the case, then I think it’s fair to say that EBay’s interests are underrepresented on Craigslist’s board. EBay has every right to that representation because it paid for shares of the company. That’s exactly what shares of the company represent — and Mr. Newmark and Mr. Buckmaster know that.

    I certainly would be saddened to see Craigslist change and become more commercial, but if it does, don’t blame EBay. Blame Mr. Newmark for not being more judicious in issuing shares of his company. He is the one who decided early on to issue shares to someone who wasn’t on board with his long-term vision for Craigslist — someone who would later sell out. And also blame Mr. Newmark for not putting together a more equitable board that includes representation for EBay. Had he done so, EBay probably would not have grounds for the lawsuit they are filing.

  139. brian Says:

    Here we go a fight…… I’m a member to both services e-bay and craigslist.org..

    Sounds like ebay wants everyone to pay there fee’s and dissolve craigslist.org in the furture.. Glad you all foresaw this..

    Lawsuits and money and agreements…. “Can’t we all get along

    I would like to sell my Chopper But I can’t afford E-bay at this time..

    If those e’bayers start slinging mud …
    I WILL NEVER USE THEIR SERVICES IN MY LIFE TIME..

  140. Ob1 Says:

    They just tipped their hand, this was their plan from the beginning. Anyone surprised, is just being naive.

    Maybe the time is ripe for a CLASS ACTION lawsuit or three, against ebay from all the people who they have tried to manipulate. It isn’t hard to come up with grounds on a number of fronts.
    Write to the FTC & complain about Feeborg & Payfool’s monopolistic practices. My, there’s a class action suit just waiting to happen, right there!

  141. PW Says:

    We eBay sellers may just be noise, but Craigslist has a great opportunity not just to defend itself against eBay, but to be the first one to cause difficulty to eBay in its disrespectful and arrogant path that focuses on profit and nothing else.

  142. Jay Mann Says:

    Does ebay EVER get tired of fucking it’s customers? How many times have I (or you) heard the sentence ” I USED to sell on ebay”? I’ve said and heard it at least one thousand times, minimum.

  143. Jay Mann Says:

    And one more thing:

    FUCK EBAY

    ………..just had to say it…………….you know how it is…….let’s make it an internet mantra

  144. Sandra Campbell Says:

    You guys rock!!! The ebay refugees are all rooting for you. Ebay is pretty much out to screw everyone these days. Don’t give in just because they happen to be the biggest bully on the block. Just wish you would start your own alternative auction site.

  145. Sandra Campbell Says:

    http://forums.ebay.com/db2/thread.jspa?threadID=2000556933&tstart=0&mod=1209019309039

    So you will know that you are truly our heroes.

  146. Steve Says:

    In the past 3 months, I sold about $750 on eBay and bought about $2200 worth the goods. I also sold $1000 on craigslist for an old tool (Delta DJ20 Jointer) and bought about $400 worth the goods. I view both sites as equalizers for the middle class. As retail prices get ever higher you can always find used equivalents cheaper through these two sites.

    I am deeply bothered about this malevolent lawsuit. Our nation has become an extraordinary nation of greedy businessmen. I think, as a small guy, boycotting eBay would be one way to send a message that their malevolent actions do not meet with my approval. If enough eBayers (100,000+) have a similar reaction and let eBay know their sentiments, may be eBay will reconsider its greed.

  147. Greg P Says:

    Simply put … It all boils down to greed.

  148. Ebay Blogger Says:

    I’m researching the feelings and attitudes towards Ebay by current and ex members and issues like this are invaluable to it, I to like the format of Craigslist and hope sincerely that you keep working as your members want (which you do very well now).

    Have bookmarked the blog and will be avidly reading the comments that it receives…

  149. Blondie Says:

    Ebay is a GIANT monster and will go at great lengths to step on people and companies that they feel get in their GREEDY way! As an ex-seller on ebay we are boycotting Ebay May 1st to stop this Greed Craigslist has given so many people an opportunity without any selfish whims! YOU GO CRAIG! Don’t let this monster push you down!

    http://forums.delphiforums.com/boycottebay
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zs3o3Ed3Rog
    http://www.accknowl.com/

  150. Jan Says:

    Well eBay blogger, eBay is a PITA to use, they encourage a monopoly by paypal, the site is too complex and too commercial. I was looking for a used travel trailer and all I got when I searched was a bunch of RV dealers pushing their wares, with ads repeating over and over.

    On top of that, someone stole my identity there once, I had to go to the real time help site to get that cleared up! My user name there is jan_rn, I haven’t used the site for years, I was only a buyer.

    Paypal also turned out to be a PITA, and I have no idea what email I’m even registered on with them. I hate the unholy alliance between paypal and eBay.

    This lawsuit seals the deal as far as my disdain for eBay, talk about bully tactics!

  151. Ob1 Says:

    (Not to get off topic; refer to my earlier posts. ) http://www.powersellersunite.com/ points to a number of useful alternative venues for those wanting to jump ship from FEEBORG/ PAYFOOL. There is a useful site volume count at http://www.powersellersunite.com/auctionsitewatch.php
    Their forums are quite helpful in coming up the learning curve. It is not sales volume alone, each venue has it peculiarities & quirks; & there are many specialty sites that may work better for some.

    ( also, don’t get suckered into buying “google adwords for free”- it’s a scam. When you Google it, remember to include ” misrepresentation” etc. or you won’t find the real information as a lot of people are hyping it.
    http://www.24hourtrading.co.uk/blog/the-get-google-ads-free-site-is-a-complete-scam-267/

    Again, it’s appropriate to organize CLASS ACTION LAWSUITS, Antitrust & probably racketeering charges against ebay/ paypal, which fronts like a bank but has skated around FTC & other regulation until now. It’s time to go after their weak spots, not just sitting around complaining about those that would pimp us. Contact your government representatives!

  152. *~Gurlz Gone Glam Lingerie~* Says:

    You can tell ebay is getting desperate when they do something so underhanded, pathetic and stupid and succeed in showing their true colors.

    They’ve been having more than their share of bad press lately (self imposed), between the fraud they promote that now runs rampant on their site to the way they’ve begun destroying the site by treating their customers (the sellers), who built them from the ground up, like last weeks trash.

    I hope this latest ebay blunder opens the eyes of many, as to what ebay truly stands for… their own dishonest, greedy, gluttonous monster appetites.

    They stand for all that is disgusting and evil in big business.

    ~~~GO CRAIG and JIM, we’re all cheering for you!~~~

    (: (: (: ~~~WE LOVE CRAIGSLIST!~~~ :) :)